ABO PETROLEUM CORPORATION V. AMSTUTZ 93 N.M. 332, 600 P.2d 278 (1979) CASE BRIEF

ABO PETROLEUM CORPORATION V. AMSTUTZ

93 N.M. 332, 600 P.2d 278 (1979)

NATURE OF THE CASE: This was an action to quiet title. Appealed. Amstutz (Ds) challenged an order, which granted Abo's (P) land claimant's motion, denied Ds' motion, and entered a partial final judgment in favor of P. P had brought the action to quiet title to certain property, claiming that his predecessors in interest acquired it by a deed.

FACTS: The Turknetts were the original fee simple owners of the property at issue. By two separate deeds, they conveyed life estates in two separate parcels of land to their daughters. Both deed provided that, upon the death of the daughter, the property would go absolutely to the children of the daughter. If the daughter died without children, the land was to go to her estate, to be distributed according to her will, or to her heirs at law. At the time these deeds were executed, neither daughter had any children. Subsequent deeds were executed in favor of both daughters which purported to convey absolute title to the same lands covered in the original deeds. After all of the deeds had been executed, both daughters had children (D). Both daughters also attempted to convey fee simple interests in the land to the predecessors of Abo (P). D argues that since the 1908 deeds conveyed life estates only, that is all the daughters could have conveyed to P's predecessors. P argues that the subsequent deeds vested the daughters with fee simple interests, and that their predecessors therefore took fee simple title. The court found that the original deeds created life estates with alternative contingent remainders in D and in the daughters' estates, and that therefore, the Turknetts retained a reversionary interest in the property after executing the original deeds.

ISSUE:

RULE OF LAW:

HOLDING AND DECISION:

LEGAL ANALYSIS:

Get free access to the entire content for Mac, PC or Online

for 2-3 days and free samples of all kinds of products.

https://bsmsphd.com

© 2007-2016 Abn Study Partner