MATTER OF VITRO S.A.B. de C.V.
701 F.3d 1031 (5th Cir. 2012)
NATURE OF THE CASE: Creditors appealed an affirmance of a bankruptcy court's recognition
of a Mexican reorganization proceeding and its foreign representatives under Bankruptcy Code
Chapter 15. The debtor and a 3rd-party creditor appealed the bankruptcy court's denial of
enforcement of the Mexican reorganization plan because the plan would release the debtor's
non-debtor subsidiary guarantors.
FACTS: Three cases were consolidated relating to the Mexican reorganization proceeding of
Vitro S.A.B. de C.V., a corporation organized under the laws of Mexico. Vitro S.A.B. de C.V.
(Vitro) is a holding company that, together with its subsidiaries, constitutes the largest
glass manufacturer in Mexico. Vitro employs approximately 17,000 workers, the majority of
whom work in Mexico. Vitro borrowed a total of approximately $1.216 billion, predominately
from United States investors. There are three series of unsecured notes. The first series
was issued on October 22, 2003 and consisted of $225 million aggregate principal amount of
11.75% notes due 2013; the second and third series were issued on February 1, 2007, and
consisted of $300 million of 8.625% notes due 2012 and $700 million of 9.125% notes due 2017
(collectively the 'Old Notes'). Payment in full of the Old Notes was guaranteed by all of
Vitro's subsidiaries (the 'Guarantors'). The obligations of the Guarantors were not to be
released, discharged, or otherwise affected by any settlement or release as a result of any
insolvency, reorganization, or bankruptcy proceeding affecting Vitro. The guaranties were to
be governed and construed under New York law and include the Guarantors' consent to litigate
any disputes in New York state courts. In February of 2009, Vitro announced its intention to
restructure its debt and stopped making scheduled interest payments on the Old Notes. Vitro
entered into a sale leaseback transaction with Fintech Investments Ltd. ('Fintech'), one of
its largest third-party creditors, holding approximately $600 million in claims (including
$400 million in Old Notes). Fintech paid $75 million in exchange for the creation, in its
favor, of a Mexican trust composed of real estate contributed by Vitro's subsidiaries. This
real estate was then leased to one of Vitro's subsidiaries to continue normal operations.
The agreement also gave Fintech the right to acquire 24% of Vitro's outstanding capital or
shares of a sub-holding company owned by Vitro in exchange for transferring Fintech's
interest in the trust back to Vitro or its subsidiaries. Vitro generated a large quantity of
intercompany debt. Vitro's operating subsidiaries owed Vitro an aggregate of approximately
$1.2 billion in intercompany debt. That debt was wiped out and, Vitro's subsidiaries became
creditors to which Vitro owed an aggregate of approximately $1.5 billion in intercompany
debt. Vitro did not disclose these transactions. Fintech purchased claims by five banks
holding claims against Vitro and extended the maturity of various promissory notes issued by
Vitro's subsidiaries. Fintech also agreed not to transfer any debt it held in Vitro unless
such transfer was in line with the terms of that agreement. Three hundred days after
completing the transactions with its subsidiaries, Vitro disclosed the existence of the
subsidiary creditors. This took the transactions outside Mexico's 270-day 'suspicion
period,' during which such transactions would be subject to additional scrutiny before a
business enters bankruptcy. Vitro initiated in a Mexican court a concurso proceeding under
the Mexican Business Reorganization Act, or Ley de Concursos Mercantiles (LCM). Eventually
Vitro was declared to be in bankruptcy. The conciliador filed an initial list of recognized
claims and mediated the creation of a reorganization plan. The Old Notes would be
extinguished and the obligations owed by the Guarantors would be discharged. Vitro would
issue new notes payable in 2019 with a total principal amount of $814,650,000. The New 2019
Notes would be issued to Vitro's third-party creditors (not including those subsidiaries
holding intercompany debt who would receive other promissory notes. The New 2019 Notes would
also 'be unconditionally and supportively guaranteed for each of the Guarantors.' Under
Mexican law, approval of a reorganization plan requires votes by creditors holding at least
50% in aggregate principal amount of unsecured debt. Mexico counts the votes of all
unsecured creditors, including insiders, as a single class. Over 50% of all voting claims
were held by Vitro's subsidiaries in the form of intercompany debt. The Mexican court
approved the Concurso plan. Dissatisfied creditors filed involuntary Chapter 11 petitions
against fifteen Guarantors domiciled in the United States. They sought a declaratory
judgment confirming the Guarantors' obligations under the related indentures. The court held
that New York law applied to the dispute and that under the unambiguous terms of the
relevant Old Notes, 'any non-consensual release, discharge or modification of the
obligations of the Guarantors . . . is prohibited.' The court went on to find, however, that
'whether such prohibitive provisions may be modified or eliminated by applicable Mexican
laws is not at issue here.' Vitro commenced a Chapter 15 proceeding in United States
bankruptcy court by filing a petition for recognition of the Mexican concurso proceeding.
The bankruptcy court denied the Enforcement Motion. The court also denied Vitro's motion to
enjoin the Objecting Creditors from initiating litigation against the Guarantors. The
bankruptcy court granted recognition of the concurso proceeding as a foreign main proceeding
under 11 U.S.C. 1517. On appeal, the district court affirmed, holding that it was
sufficient that the representatives were authorized as co-foreign representatives in the
context of a foreign bankruptcy proceeding and that Vitro retained sufficient control over
its business to be a debtor in possession.
ISSUE:
RULE OF LAW:
HOLDING AND DECISION:
LEGAL ANALYSIS:
Get
free access to the entire content for Mac, PC or Online
for 2-3 days and free samples
of all kinds of products.
for 2-3 days and free samples of all kinds of products.
https://bsmsphd.com
© 2007-2016 Abn Study Partner
No comments:
Post a Comment